Who wore it best? Cheryl Cole vs. Lucy Liu

We thought we recognised Cheryl's purple and pink X Factor frock - and that's because Lucy's already worn it

Who wore it best? Cheryl Cole vs. Lucy Liu - Ina Soltani, dress, stars, wearing, same, matching, outfit, style, snap, X Factor, Marie Claire
Who wore it best? Cheryl Cole vs. Lucy Liu - Ina Soltani, dress, stars, wearing, same, matching, outfit, style, snap, X Factor, Marie Claire
(Image credit: Rex Features)

We thought we recognised Cheryl's purple and pink X Factor frock - and that's because Lucy's already worn it

When Cheryl Cole hit the X Factor stage this weekend, we thought we recognised her pink and purple strapless frock - and that's because Lucy Liu had already worn it.

SEE MORE STARS PLAYING STYLE SNAP HERE!

Cheryl stepped on stage in this striking strapless Ina Soltani dress during the X Factor Sunday night results show.

The judge teamed the colourful creation with an elegant updo, suede Christian Louboutin pumps and de Grisogono sphere earrings.

But, rewind 6 months, and Lucy Liu was first to give the frock it's high-profile debut.

Who wore it best? Cheryl Cole vs. Lucy Liu - Ina Soltani, dress, stars, wearing, same, matching, outfit, style, snap, X Factor, Marie Claire

The actress donned the very same dress to the Actor's Fund Annual Gala in New York back in April - with the only difference being that her version had a slightly longer skirt.

A swishing ponytail, classic black courts, purple statement earrings and a box clutch completed the red carpet look from the Charlie's Angel.

Who wore it best? Cheryl Cole vs. Lucy Liu - Ina Soltani, dress, stars, wearing, same, matching, outfit, style, snap, X Factor, Marie Claire

Two stylish stars, one designer dress - but who gets YOUR vote in the style stakes? Let us know in the comments box below!

SEE MORE STARS PLAYING STYLE SNAP HERE!

SEE ALL THE LATEST X FACTOR FASHION

The leading destination for fashion, beauty, shopping and finger-on-the-pulse views on the latest issues. Marie Claire's travel content helps you delight in discovering new destinations around the globe, offering a unique – and sometimes unchartered – travel experience. From new hotel openings to the destinations tipped to take over our travel calendars, this iconic name has it covered.