Katie Holmes is trying to bring back this Y2K outfit formula and it has divided the internet
Yes or no? You be the judge.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/0eb88/0eb88e870905e9904539abea25d3e49579776a21" alt="Katie Holmes on the red carpet 2022"
Let's take a trip down memory lane, shall we? Cast your mind back to 2004. It was a time when Mean Girls had just hit cinemas, The O.C. was in its prime, tabloids were filled with rumours about Paris Hilton and Jennifer Lopez had just called off her engagement to Ben Affleck...the first time around.
Sartorially speaking, the early aughts was an era when "going out tops" reigned, and you could practically wear denim to just about any and every occasion. Red carpets were filled with starlets dressed in "jeans and a nice top," while minidresses were often accessorised alongside three-quarter leggings or (you guessed it) jeans underneath.
Evidently, Katie Holmes is feeling nostalgic for these times as over the weekend she appeared at the iHeart Radio Jingle Ball dressed in a look that can only be described as a complete throwback.
Featuring a strapless bustier top by UK-label Tove (or boob-tube top as we used to refer to them in the noughties) and relaxed, wide-leg denim jeans from Reformation, you would not be mistaken for thinking that the image above was taken in the early 2000s. Though despite the fact that Katie Holmes has barely aged a day since appearing on Dawson's Creek, I can confirm that this photo is in fact from December 2022.
With Y2K fashion trending all over again, thanks to TikTok, it should come as little surprise that we have now seen the return of the long top over jeans look. Afterall, the outfit formula was once championed by early-2000s It-girls including Mischa Barton, Lindsay Lohan and Vanessa Hudgens.
Holmes' look felt so authentic to the era, that if it wasn't for the resolution of the images, you could justifiably presume that the two photos above were taken at the same event. When they were, in fact, taken a whole 18 years apart.
Unsurprisingly, Twitter had an absolute field day with this look.
Marie Claire Newsletter
Celebrity news, beauty, fashion advice, and fascinating features, delivered straight to your inbox!
Katie Holmes woke up & decided it was 2002 pic.twitter.com/0yDOyuLL6ZDecember 11, 2022
Katie Holmes serving Anne Hathaway Ella Enchanted premiere circa 2004 pic.twitter.com/LBsviUNGqkDecember 11, 2022
I unfortunately cannot comment on the Katie Holmes dress top + jeans combo because I too lived through the early 00’s and made decisions I regretDecember 11, 2022
They say that everything old is new again, and that definitely stands true in this instance. Are we ready to embrace minidresses over jeans again? We'll let you be the judge of that one.
Zoe Anastasiou is a Fashion Editor with over eight years of experience working across digital publications in New York, London and Australia. She has contributed to publications including Harper’s BAZAAR and ELLE Australia, and was the Fashion and Social Media Editor at Who What Wear UK before joining Marie Claire.
-
The viral White Lotus theory could actually have a subtle second meaning - and it makes a lot of sense
By Jadie Troy-Pryde
-
These are the chic yet comfortable sandals our editors are already investing in for Spring
It's never too early
By Sofia Piza
-
Andrea's It List: 7 key travel essentials for fashion month
The most useful investment pieces for fashion month from Marie Claire's Editor In Chief Andrea Thompson
By Andrea Thompson